A bunch of middle-aged people get together to form a hobby
group that gains enough notoriety to be featured in a TV show and/or
documentary, which in turn gets turned into a dramatised film. This is one of
those situations where I find myself reflecting on just how many times I’ve
covered stories like this on here and how, with barely any exceptions, they
usually just fall into the realms of ‘meh’ for me. Best case scenario, I end up
being pleasantly surprised, albeit still not all that jazzed about it, and
worse case, it turns into another Poms where I end up questioning what the
filmmakers even think of their own audience. And with this one…
honestly, I didn’t end up feeling either of those.
Kristin Scott Thomas has already proven that she can tear
the roof off with the right material, like with The Party, and after Sharon
Horgan’s turn in Game Night, I don’t see any reason to doubt her abilities
either. However, seeing them regularly bickering as the duelling heads of the
choir is pretty lame stuff. There’s a smidge of subtext to be gotten out of
their methods, from Thomas’ Kate who runs the choir meetups like official
lessons, while Horgan’s Lisa just wants to them to engage regardless of talent
(a weirdly punk attitude, all things considered), but that doesn’t really lead
to anything. Well, anything that could separate this from the norms of this
sub-genre.
As for the sounds of the choir itself, there’s at least some
engagement to be gotten out of their own present enjoyment in basically being
the older generation’s Pitch Perfect. The song choices are decent, or at least
make sense for this crowd, and the smaller moments like them talking about
including Dido’s Thank You into their repertoire, with Lisa bringing up
Eminem’s remix of that on Stan… yeah, I’m fairly predictable about shit like
this, but that was a nice touch.
But with that said, while the singing is fine, it’s rather
embarrassing just how lifeless composer Lorne Balfe’s score is alongside it.
The generic orchestral string version of Cyndi Lauper’s Time After Time is so
bland, it sounds like the taste of drywall (a hell of a feat for what was originally one of the best love songs of all time), and the rest of his work painfully
fades into the background, one right after the other. It’s enough to make me
wish that they probably should have just dumped the non-diegetic soundtrack and
have the cast do all the legwork, but that would make this more interesting and
potentially unique against its contemporaries, and there’s clearly no room for
that here.
Another example of being perfectly adequate and something
I’m likely to completely forget about before the week’s out, Military Wives is
admittedly a non-painful sit but the sheer arse-numbing nature of the humour,
the listless story and the tired plot beats more than make up for that. I can
see older audiences getting into this for a mild diversion, and more power to
them if they actually end up liking this, but as for me, it’s just… a film that
exists. I don’t even have that strong an opinion on it, honestly.
No comments:
Post a Comment