Fresh off
the smash success of Top Gun: Maverick, a rousing display of American pop
cinema that felt like a return to normalcy after the last couple years’ worth
of COVID calamity, Joseph Kosinski’s other film from 2022… kinda feels
like a rebuttal to his own work.
It’s set in
the titular prison complex, where the inmates are given a degree of freedom and
leisure in return for participating in drug trials run by the charismatic Steve
Abnesti (Chris Hemsworth). The story primarily focuses on the idea of emotional
modification, and pharmaceuticals in general, as a deconstruction of the very
idea of control and free will in the face of something capable of so utterly
altering a person’s state of mind. A bit odd that this comes hot on the heels
of what is essentially military propaganda as cinematic art (not saying it’s
bad, just calling it how I see it), but makes a little more sense with how limp
the commentary gets here.
I mean, the
circumstances behind the people who are in Spiderhead as volunteers raises some
interesting ideas. Wanting to alter themselves as a kind of retroactive
correction for past sins (an idea that I have quite a soft spot for), what it
says about standard American prisons when this is seen as the better
alternative, or even taking the self-punishment aspect of imprisonment further
through some of the scarier applications of chemical influence shown here. The
actors do well with their roles here, from Miles Teller as one of the inmates
Jeff, Jurnee Smollett as his love interest Lizzy, Mark Paguio as the complicit
bystander in the experiments, and Hemsworth especially brings some of that El Royale swagger to his presence here as the guy overseeing the whole thing.
However,
those performance high points are often the result of trying to work against
the material given, rather than with, and I don’t exactly blame them for doing
that. Writers Rhett Reese and Paul Wernick are capable of fine work when
they’re being sly or subversive or just straight goofy, but cold and calculated
satire isn’t exactly in their toolset. As such, their feature-length adaptation
of what was originally a short story published in the New Yorker comes with some pretty juvenile moments. The ‘Shitfingers’ running joke felt entirely
unnecessary, and as much as I kinda get the gratuitous sex scenes as
part of the overall theme of emotional manipulation, the framing ventures a
little too close to my Berserk Button concerning ‘sexual abuse towards
men = comedy’. It’s like an adolescent attempt at a Black Mirror story, and even
when that show was at its silliness, it never got quite to this
point.
It doesn’t
help that the script doesn’t really go anywhere with its ideas. Or, at least,
anywhere that hasn’t already been explored in other stories. Much like Steve
himself, it seems to be a lot more focused on just how people react to certain
stimuli than getting any deeper into the implications and ramifications of such
stimuli. The examination of the importance we place on emotions is decent
enough, and I like how it manifests in Steve mainly as someone with more money
than stability desperately looking for approval (again, quite a familiar read
for today’s high-and-mighty), but as sci-fi meant to provoke thought, it
doesn’t do a whole lot.
This whole
production feels like a middle-of-the-road side project for all involved.
Nothing too daring, nothing too intense, nothing too thorny, and yet nothing too
objectionable either. The cast are alright, the visuals get a lot of mileage
out of the Queensland landscape, and even if it’s unfortunately shallow, it
makes at least some decent points about the human desire for a cheap fix
to their emotional problems. This was always going to feel smaller in
comparison to Top Gun: Maverick, both as cinema and as pop culture impact
event, but I was hoping that it would be a little more substantial than this.