The 1961
film adaptation of West Side Story is widely considered to be one of the
greatest films of all time, let alone musical films. And while I definitely get
everything that makes it so memorable (the choreography, the music, the
reworking of classic Shakespeare), I wouldn’t say it’s among my favourite
musical films out there. Sure, that could just be because I’m so accustomed to
how much it’s influenced pop culture since its release that I’m not able to
appreciate it as much on its own terms, but in my own defense, both the film
and the original stage musical feel like dry runs for things that the creatives
involved would end up perfecting later on.
As a grand
big-screen musical directed by Robert Wise, it’s good… but it’s no Sound Of
Music. As a musical with lyrics from theatre extraordinaire Stephen Sondheim (who
tragically passed away earlier this year), it’s good… but it’s no Sweeney Todd
or Into The Woods.
So, yeah,
I’m already a little bit lukewarm on the original production as is… but I’ll be
honest, I can at least understand why someone would try and remake the
film today. As much as I can sympathise with how the Hays code really did a
number on a lot of productions at the time through executive meddling and
general BS to do with non-white romantic leads, having a film all about
conflict between different racial cultures, while half of the cast is in full
brownface, makes it difficult for that intent to ring through.
As such, remaking
it at a time when… well, I won’t say that colorism is no longer a thing within
the industry (and not just in Hollywood either), but at least when filmmakers
are under less pressure to pull heavy makeup tactics, could help revive it for
a new generation. Hell, even though Steven Spielberg somehow hasn’t made
a musical before this, he’s done pretty much everything else under the sun, so
he’s as good a choice as any to give it a crack. And it’s an
attempt that seems to have worked out for the better, as it manages to keep
everything that makes the original musical what it is, but with just
enough modernisation to help translate it into a post-millennium film market.